What a separate PIM actually buys you, what BigCommerce, DynamicWeb and Sana Commerce already handle, three questions on channels, attributes and launch workflow, where each PIM vendor fits, and the one-week assessment to run first.
Read the full write-up: Do you actually need a PIM?
Chapters
- 0:00Intro
- 0:36What a PIM buys you
- 1:34What your platform already does
- 2:14Three questions
- 2:44Counting attributes
- 3:05Scoring the answers
- 3:21If you do need one
- 4:00DynamicWeb and PIM
- 4:23What to do first
- 5:03Next steps
Shorts from this video
DynamicWeb already has a PIM built in (0:23)
Before you buy a PIM, run this one-week check (0:40)
Salsify, inRiver, Akeneo or Pimcore: which PIM fits (0:40)
Four things a PIM actually buys you (0:58)
Do you need a PIM? Count your yeses (0:16)
Transcript
Intro
Every B2B platform pitch eventually gets to the same line. And you'll want a PIM. PIM stands for product information management. It's a separate system that holds your product data, with names like Salsify, inRiver, Akeneo and Pimcore. Sometimes buying one is right. Often it isn't. A separate PIM means a licence, integration work, training, and ongoing decisions about who owns the data. In this video, we'll cover what a PIM actually buys you, what your platform already handles, three questions that decide it, and what to do first.
What a PIM buys you
Genuine PIM value comes from one or more of four things. The first is publishing to many channels. If the same product goes to your storefront, Amazon, a print catalog, your dealers' sites and a sales rep app, keeping attributes in all of those systems is a nightmare. A PIM centralizes them. The second is a rich attribute model. Technical specs, regulatory data, descriptions in several languages, photos, CAD files and safety data sheets. The ERP can't express that, and the storefront only needs a fraction of it. The third is editorial workflow. Copywriting, photography, technical review and legal sign-off, behind one publish gate. Spreadsheets and ERPs don't do that. PIMs do. And the fourth is regional data. A truly multi-region operation has its own product copy, units and SKU mappings per region, and needs a system of record for them outside the ERP.
What your platform already does
The commerce platforms have grown serious product information features of their own. Here are three we work with. BigCommerce has product modifiers, custom fields, complex SKU rules, and price list awareness in B2B Edition. For a catalog of one thousand to fifty thousand SKUs going to one or two channels, it's usually enough. DynamicWeb ships with PIM as a first-class module of the platform. There's no need to bolt on a separate one. It's already there. Sana Commerce uses the ERP as the catalog's source of truth. If your ERP item master is well curated, that's a perfectly valid substitute for a PIM.
Three questions
So do you need a separate PIM? We ask three questions. The first is how many channels the catalog goes to. With one channel, built-in is fine. With three or more, a separate PIM saves real labour. The second is how rich your attribute model is. We'll look at the numbers in a moment. The third is whether a product launch needs a multi-step workflow with reviewers. If not, built-in is fine. If it does, a separate PIM's editorial features pay for themselves.
Counting attributes
Count the attributes on a typical product. Every spec, every piece of regulatory data, every asset. Under about thirty attributes per product, your platform's built-in product info handles it. At fifty or more, including multimedia and regulatory data, that points to a separate PIM.
Scoring the answers
Now count your yeses across the three questions. Two yeses out of three usually means a separate PIM is justified. One yes is borderline. And with one yes or none, someone may be selling you a PIM you don't need.
If you do need one
If the answers say you need one, the vendor landscape is sprawling. These are four we've worked with productively. Akeneo has a strong editorial workflow that suits B2B, a good ecosystem, and runs self-hosted or in the cloud. Salsify is particularly strong at publishing to retail channels like Amazon and Walmart. It's heavier than you need if your channels are all your own. Pimcore is open source, and also handles digital assets and customer data. It's very flexible, and it takes commitment to run well. And inRiver is a mature B2B product. It's often the right answer for industrial and manufacturing catalogs.
DynamicWeb and PIM
One platform deserves its own note. DynamicWeb ships with PIM as a first-class module of the platform, so it is already there. For DynamicWeb projects, our answer is almost always the same. Use the built-in PIM unless you have a specific reason not to. Wiring a third-party PIM into DynamicWeb adds integration debt without a clear payoff.
What to do first
Before anyone commits to a PIM project, we run a one-week assessment. First, audit the current product master, across the ERP, spreadsheets and sales ops files. Second, diagram every channel that consumes product data. Third, score the editorial workflow on the three questions. And fourth, estimate the ongoing cost of owning the data. A PIM with no dedicated data steward is a PIM that decays. A meaningful number of those assessments end the same way. You don't need a separate PIM. You need discipline around the tools you already have. That's a six-week project, against a six-month one.
Next steps
So ask the three questions. Channels, attributes and launch workflow. Two yeses, and a separate PIM is usually worth it. If you're being pitched a PIM right now and aren't sure you need it, we'll give you a real read, even if it costs us the PIM project. The full write-up, with the decision tree and the vendor notes, is on projectthunder.com. Thanks for watching.
Narration is an AI voice (Azure). The facts come from the linked write-up.


